( I understand this book was published as Sophia’s Secret in the UK.)

The Winter sea was my book for the last 10 days in my book every 1o day challenge. (yes few days early.)
Susanna Kearsley has written a part historical, part present day novel set in Scotland. It may just be that I was born in Scotland and spent quite a bit of time sitting in a class room listening ( sleeping) to the history played out in this book or it might be that Kearsley didn’t read As you know, Bob
I’m not sure which applies but The Winter Sea is loaded with Historical information. Pages and pages, that go on for chapters and chapters. There is little white space as in dialogue and a great deal of time spent reading historical information so the reader understands the time period. I do mean a lot.
The first few chapters were enjoyable and I settled in expecting more of the same. That didn’t happen for me.
If you are interested in the Jacobite plot of 1708 to return the last Stewart king to the throne of Scotland this is a good text-book for you. If a great deal of historical detail makes you sleepy you might not be interested. This novel mentions a few of my long dead descendents and for that reason held on, but for no other reason. I was bored for the most part. I didn’t care about the love triangle forming and I didn’t care about the historical flashes.
The plot centers around Carrie McClelland, a best-selling romance writer ( how many books have you read recently where the protagonist is a best-selling author) is struggling with her latest book and on a visit to a ruin on the coast of Scotland feels drawn to the area. The story and people come to her in dreams and she finds herself writing unconsciously. The historical romance she is writing is told to us in historical form by Sophia Paterson, an ancestor of Carrie’s.
Carrie is falling in love, just as Sophia is. The coincidences are a little contrived and much of the story is guessed before read. There is tragedy aplenty but most of that is told to us with a very cold voice. There are some lovely moments of prose in the novel but it fell short for me. The story line of remembering through some DNA connection wasn’t strong enough. I would have liked more of it.
Thrash me once again for going with popularity and buying this because 200 people on amazon loved it and gave it 5 stars. I have done this before and been dissappointed.
I can not say this is poorly written. It’s not. But the mass of information and the slow plot bothered me. Is it that I have to concede that Romance novels don’t do it for me? I love Sarah Addison Allen, and they are romances. I fly through those, but this one I plodded.
Onwards to a new 10 days.
Like this:
3 bloggers like this post.